"'Ere, Mister 'Orne..."
I’m a big fan of BBC Radio 7, the DAB station which outputs a load of vintage radio comedy shows.
I’m also keen on the 6.30pm comedy slot on BBC Radio 4, but in recent weeks the contrast between the two has been palpable.
Take Tuesday’s Radio 4 output – Too Much Information – and the 8am slot this morning on Radio 7, Round the Horne.
The latter episode was 42 years old and still makes me chortle; the former, which claims to be a comedy based in a tourist information office, simply made me shake my head in disbelief. I’ve heard funnier news bulletins.
What is it that commissioning editors look for currently in new shows? One would hope it was humour, but that clearly is no longer a pre-requisite.
Shows of the quality of Round the Horne would, quite simply, never be given the go-ahead in the BBC of the 21st century. It’s far too concerned with being politically correct, and inoffensive – the BBC’s ‘fun police’ are the broadcasting equivalent of the health and safety executive.
Round the Horne is too near the knuckle; too dangerous; too camp; just too damned funny.
Take this morning’s episode. Kenneth Horne is a special agent and catches Robin Day trying to climb the BBC’s equivalent of the Berlin Wall.
“I’m trying to defect over the wall,” explains Bill Pertwee as Day.
“Well,” says Horne, slowly,, in that wonderful deep brown voice, “it’s a clever trick if you can do it.”
It requires the art of innuendo – and it is an art in its highest form – and, in the listener, a decent command of the English language.
Perhaps that’s the answer. The general population is no longer able to appreciate clever or subtle humour so we get programmes devoid of any form of it.
Too many of today’s shows pander to the lowest common denominator. And I’m not saying that because I’m in my 40s. I can see why the younger generation would like things like We Are Klang. I’ve laughed at it myself, despite the fact it’s not aimed at the likes of me.
But the BBC wouldn’t let Round the Horne through these days for myriad reasons, not least for fear sketches like Jules and Sandy might offend homosexuals or that minors might be corrupted by the cordwanglings of Rambling Syd Rumpo.
Rambing Syd was completely inoffensive; it’s only in the mind of the listener that it becomes suggestive. A classic example of the British love of innuendo.
And as for Jules and Sandy, Kenneth Williams was as camp as a row of tents in real life and if he had no problems playing the part why should people be offended by hearing it?
Indeed one of the biggest Round the Horne fans I know is a gay woman. She loves it. And she’s quite keen on Round the Horne… did you see what I did there?
The gist of what I’m trying to say is that anybody out there with a modicum of comedic writing skill should be haranguing the BBC with anything they’ve penned. And anybody with an interest in enjoying comedy should be haranguing the BBC to commission some decent stuff without running it past the fun police first.
It's shocking to think that had the current climate been prevailing 30, 40 and 50 years ago we would never have had Round the Horne, Are You Being Served, It Ain't 'Alf Hot Mum, Til Death Us Do Part, The Goon Show, Monty Python's Flying Circus and many other great comedy shows.
It doesn't bear thinking about.
*And if you’re really interested in following my advice, the controller of BBC comedy commissioning is Cheryl Taylor (http://www.bbc.co.uk/commissioning/tv/network/genres/comedy.shtml)
I share your appreciation of 'Round the Horne' but don't think the banal offerings today are the result of the 'thought police' (Little Britain is certainly not PC)....more a question of dumbing down. There have been some other good offerings on TV (Early Doors, The Thick of it); maybe it is just radio which has lost its way.
ReplyDeleteCharlie Barber
Yebbut Charlie, Little Britain wasn't funny after series one. Like the Fast Show, Catherine Tate and Armstrong and Miller it all became too formulaic and predictable.
ReplyDeleteYou'd think the recurring characters in RTH would have meant the same fate, but somehow it stayed fresh. Maybe that's the beauty of radio...
Bunky
I remember obtaining a book of Round the Horne scripts when I was about thirteen. The line that made me laugh most was the one about defecting over the wall. I also recall one that I trot out on occasions, and which usually brings baffled looks. It's when Jules and Sandy are providing the catering for an event and say that they could lay on a buffet. Kenneth Horne's response - "I didn't expect a cabaret". Thanks for the memories.
ReplyDeletePhil